by Jessie Daye
My ice cream containers: Large Ice Cream Tubs Buy Here
My Pint size Ice cream containers: Small Pint Ice Cream Tubs Buy Here
Other condensed milk options:
My ice cream containers: Large Ice Cream Tubs Buy Here
My Pint size Ice cream containers: Small Pint Ice Cream Tubs Buy Here
Other condensed milk options:
This post may contain affiliate links, please see our privacy policy for details.
I’m a Los Angeles mama, home renovator, and lifelong creative, sharing the things that make everyday life a little more beautiful. I believe food is one of the best ways to bring people together, which is why I love cooking: it turns an ordinary Tuesday into something worth remembering. From recipes I make on repeat to DIY projects, home design, and a little bit of real life in between — welcome to my corner of the internet. I’m so glad you’re here.
Be the first to receive exclusive content, hear about upcoming collaborations, and special events!
29 comments
Lynn
This is soooo good!!!!
Nancy Moncrief
Where is the recipe?
Karla Kahn
Only pictures – please post recipe
Clarissa Smithee
Why do you tell us to go to your website where you’ve posted the recipe and it’s not here? I sort of feel catfished.
Joann Cuomo
recipe??
Diane Marks
I got the link immediately with the recipe and pictures ….no problem …
Rose Lumanlan
What brand of heavy cream do you use? Thank you.
Fiona
Making this for Sunday dinner tomorrow. Tasting divine as it heads into the freezer !
My only concern will be if it’s icy once frozen. Time will tell .
timothy
I appreciate you sharing this recipe however instead of sweetened condensed milk I added honey and blueberries
Jessica
Can I also use vanilla extract instead of the paste?
Jessie Daye
Yes absolutely
Katherine
This is absolutely amazing. Super simple and does not get icy! How do I get the recipes for the other flavors?
Jessie Daye
Hi – I linked them on my other ice cream post. I am the process of rebuilding our website with printable recipe cards and links so it will be so much more cohesive in a few weeks!
Kis
Amazing! Thanks
Jessie Daye
Thank you!
Lorelie
Where do you get vanilla paste?
Jessie Daye
I buy mine at Costco because it’s cheaper there, but I also link it on Amazon because it’s still cheaper than in the grocery store. Xx
Emma Mobbs
Thank you so much, utterly delicious x
Jessie Daye
Thank you!
Jessie Daye
Ahhh same! Enjoy in the Uk!
Charla Dvorak
I tried this recipe today and it was absolutely delicious. I love all things lemon and I can’t wait for my husband to try it. Thank you so much!
Frances Listh
Lemon extract?? Is that just lemon juice , otherwise I don’t think it’s available where I live.
Stephanie
Is there a printable version?
Inez
How many servings does this recipe make? Im trying to figure out the calories
Thanks
Charles McGuire
I have a tiny batch ice cream freezer, have you tried it with a churn-style freezer?
lisa
Made this today and it was FANTASTIC! The perfect summer dessert. Thank you.
One question: how long will it stay fresh in the freezer?
Sally
What’s vanilla paste
Boddy
It’s literally vanilla beans mashed into a paste so very vanillary. You can use good vanilla drops too. Not the chemical ones.
Barry
How do you make the vanilla paste?